Released on February 14, 2025, Automatic is The Lumineers’ fifth studio album and marks a reflective chapter in their twenty-year collaboration. With Wesley Schultz and Jeremiah Fraites now navigating parenthood, the album channels the quiet turbulence, fleeting humor, and tender introspection of domestic life into its songwriting. The result is a collection that feels both intimate and measured, exploring the tension between human connection and the monotony of modern existence.
Recorded at Woodstock’s Utopia Studio with co-producers David Baron and Simone Felice, the album captures the band performing as a unit within a meticulously arranged studio ecosystem. The multi-instrumental setup—including dual drum kits, multiple pianos, and a layered array of guitars and vocal mics—affords the group a live, organic feel, even amidst careful production. For the first time, Schultz and Fraites share co-production credits, highlighting their deep involvement in the sonic architecture.
Musically, Automatic is more restrained than previous efforts. The opening single, Same Old Song, pairs urgent percussion with the band’s signature melodic sweep, juxtaposing energetic instrumentation against Schultz’s reflections on repetitive patterns and existential unease. Tracks like Asshole and the title track drift into subdued, contemplative spaces, while Plasticine toys with ideas of malleability and identity, accompanied by layered conversational snippets that emphasize self-reflection. Instrumentals such as Strings and Sunflowers evoke nostalgia and quiet hope, though the abrupt conclusion leaves listeners yearning for a more expansive resolution.
Lyrically, the album shines. Schultz and Fraites weave intimate, almost diary-like observations into universal meditations on love, expectation, and resilience. Yet, while the words carry weight, the arrangements occasionally lack the dynamism and folk-rooted texture that made albums like Cleopatra and Ophelia feel immediate and unforgettable.
Automatic is a contemplative and nuanced work that underscores The Lumineers’ maturity as songwriters and collaborators. It excels in moments of lyrical vulnerability and instrumental subtlety, yet it also exposes the band’s challenge in translating introspection into fully engaging musical arcs. For longtime fans, it offers a window into the quieter, more reflective side of Schultz and Fraites, even if it doesn’t always reach the anthemic highs of their earlier repertoire. – Jason Felton
httpvh://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D30l072bULU&list=RDD30l072bULU&start_radio=1